Spontaneous abortion and unexpected death: a critical discussion of Marquis on abortion.

Abstract:

:In his classic paper, 'Why abortion is immoral', Don Marquis argues that what makes killing an adult seriously immoral is that it deprives the victim of the valuable future he/she would have otherwise had. Moreover, Marquis contends, because abortion deprives a fetus of the very same thing, aborting a fetus is just as seriously wrong as killing an adult. Marquis' argument has received a great deal of critical attention in the two decades since its publication. Nonetheless, there is a potential challenge to it that seems to have gone unnoticed. A significant percentage of fetuses are lost to spontaneous abortion. Once we bring this fact to our attention, it becomes less clear whether Marquis can use his account of the wrongness of killing to show that abortion is the moral equivalent of murder. In this paper, I explore the relevance of the rate of spontaneous abortion to Marquis' classic anti-abortion argument. I introduce a case I call Unexpected Death in which someone is about to commit murder, but, just as the would-be murderer is about to strike, his would-be victim dies unexpectedly. I then ask: what does Marquis' account of killing imply about the moral status of what the would-be murderer was about to do? I consider four responses Marquis could give to this question, and I examine what implications these responses have for Marquis' strategy of using his account of the wrongness of killing an adult to show that abortion is in the same moral category.

journal_name

J Med Ethics

authors

Coleman MC

doi

10.1136/medethics-2012-100604

subject

Has Abstract

pub_date

2013-02-01 00:00:00

pages

89-93

issue

2

eissn

0306-6800

issn

1473-4257

pii

medethics-2012-100604

journal_volume

39

pub_type

杂志文章
  • Communication with the seriously ill: physicians' attitudes in Saudi Arabia.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:To study some ethical problems created by accession of a previously nomadic and traditional society to modern invasive medicine, by assessment of physicians' attitudes towards sharing information and decision-making with patients in the setting of a serious illness. DESIGN:Self-completion questionnaire admi...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.22.5.282

    authors: Mobeireek AF,al-Kassimi FA,al-Majid SA,al-Shimemry A

    更新日期:1996-10-01 00:00:00

  • Is there an objective way to compare research risks?

    abstract::Determining whether a research risk meets or exceeds a regulatory standard of risk acceptability is difficult. Recently a framework called the systematic evaluation of research risks (SERR) has been proposed as a method of comparing research risks with predetermined standards of acceptability. SERR purports to offer a...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2011-100194

    authors: Rossi J,Nelson RM

    更新日期:2012-07-01 00:00:00

  • Surgery to quieten the yelling of a demented old man.

    abstract::Robertson comments on a case presented by Gafner in the same issue of the Journal of Medical Ethics. A proposal to crush a laryngeal nerve to halt the incessant yelling of an elderly demented patient is disapproved by a medical center's surgery department for risk and ethical reasons. Robertson, an anesthesiologist,...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.13.4.198

    authors: Robertson GS

    更新日期:1987-12-01 00:00:00

  • Limited autonomy and partnership: professional relationships in health care.

    abstract::Principles of autonomy and self-determination have been upheld as vital to modern-day medical and ethical practice. However, the complexities of current health care and changes in the expectation of some patients and their families justify a review of such concepts. Their limitations and relativities may suggest that ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.15.1.12

    authors: Wilson-Barnett J

    更新日期:1989-03-01 00:00:00

  • Developing a culturally relevant bioethics for Asian people.

    abstract::Because of cultural differences between East and West, any attempt at outright adaptation of Western ideas in Asia will undoubtedly encounter problems, if not rejection. Transferring an idea from one place to another is just like transplanting an organ from a donor to a recipient--rejection is to be expected. Human cu...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.27.1.51

    authors: Tai MC,Lin CS

    更新日期:2001-02-01 00:00:00

  • Sturdy for common things: cultivating moral sensemaking on the front lines of practice.

    abstract::This essay argues that the field of bioethics should concern itself especially with the process of making moral sense that unfolds among clinicians, patients and family members during common but high-stakes conversations occurring on the front lines of practice. The essay outlines the parameters of a bioethics grounde...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2011-100084

    authors: Browning DM

    更新日期:2012-04-01 00:00:00

  • Voices of moral authority: parents, doctors and what will actually help.

    abstract::The public often believes that parents have a right to make medical decisions about their child. The idea that, in respect of children, doctors should do what parents tell them to do is problematic on the face of it. The effect of such a claim would be that a doctor who acted deliberately to harm a child would be maki...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章,评审

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2017-104705

    authors: Hain RDW

    更新日期:2018-07-01 00:00:00

  • Sham neurosurgery in patients with Parkinson's disease: is it morally acceptable?

    abstract::For a few decades, patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) have been treated with intracerebral transplantations of fetal mesencephalic tissue. The results of open trials have been variable. Double blind, placebo-controlled studies have recently been started in order to further investigate the efficacy of this new medi...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.27.3.151

    authors: Dekkers W,Boer G

    更新日期:2001-06-01 00:00:00

  • The ethics of surgery in the elderly demented patient with bowel obstruction.

    abstract:OBJECTIVE:Little has been written in the medical literature concerning the ethics of treatment of the elderly demented patient with bowel obstruction. It is one example of the issues with which we are becoming increasingly involved. We conducted a survey of our colleagues' opinions to determine current practice. DESIG...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.28.2.105

    authors: Gallagher P,Clark K

    更新日期:2002-04-01 00:00:00

  • Disabled picket Medical Research Council.

    abstract::The Handicap Division of the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child (SPUC) organized picketing of Britain's Medical Research Council to protest against trials of multivitamin supplementation for high-risk pregnant women to prevent development of spina bifida in the fetus. The trials have been condemned by man...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 新闻

    doi:10.1136/jme.10.3.165

    authors:

    更新日期:1984-09-01 00:00:00

  • Empirical research in bioethical journals. A quantitative analysis.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:The objective of this research is to analyse the evolution and nature of published empirical research in the fields of medical ethics and bioethics. DESIGN:Retrospective quantitative study of nine peer reviewed journals in the field of bioethics and medical ethics (Bioethics, Cambridge Quarterly of Healthca...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2004.011478

    authors: Borry P,Schotsmans P,Dierickx K

    更新日期:2006-04-01 00:00:00

  • Teaching, learning and assessment of medical ethics at the UK medical schools.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:To evaluate the UK undergraduate medical ethics curricula against the Institute of Medical Ethics (IME) recommendations; to identify barriers to teaching and assessment of medical ethics and to evaluate perceptions of ethics faculties on the preparation of tomorrow's doctors for clinical practice. DESIGN:Qu...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2015-103189

    authors: Brooks L,Bell D

    更新日期:2017-09-01 00:00:00

  • Why we should not seek individual informed consent for participation in health services research.

    abstract::Ethics committees now require that individuals give informed consent to much health services research, in the same way as for clinical research. This is misguided. Existing ethical guidelines do not help us decide how to seek consent in these cases, and have allowed managerial experimentation to remain largely uncheck...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章,评审

    doi:10.1136/jme.28.5.313

    authors: Cassell J,Young A

    更新日期:2002-10-01 00:00:00

  • The placebo effect in psychiatry: problem or solution?

    abstract::This opinion piece aims to situate the placebo effect within the field of psychiatric treatment. To accomplish this, the placebo is explored at the centre of an often heated debate between three discrete perspectives: the clinical trial researcher, the placebo researcher and the clinician. Each occupational perspectiv...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2013-101410

    authors: Huculak S

    更新日期:2014-06-01 00:00:00

  • AIDS legislation--turning up the heat?

    abstract::This paper is not about the medical condition of AIDS. Nor is it about the history of the condition since it was first reported in Atlanta, Georgia in 1981. It looks rather, at the catalogue of legislative and other legal responses to the spread of AIDS. The paper analyses the AIDS condition in its historical context....

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.12.4.187

    authors: Kirby MD

    更新日期:1986-12-01 00:00:00

  • Scientific evidence and best patient care practices should guide the ethics of Lyme disease activism.

    abstract::Johnson and Stricker published an opinion piece in the Journal of Medical Ethics presenting their perspective on the 2008 agreement between the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and the Connecticut Attorney General with regard to the 2006 IDSA treatment guideline for Lyme disease. Their writings indicate t...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2009.032896

    authors: Auwaerter PG,Bakken JS,Dattwyler RJ,Dumler JS,Halperin JJ,McSweegan E,Nadelman RB,O'Connell S,Sood SK,Weinstein A,Wormser GP

    更新日期:2011-02-01 00:00:00

  • Wish-fulfilling medicine in practice: the opinions and arguments of lay people.

    abstract:BACKGROUND:Wish-fulfilling medicine appears to be on the rise. It can be defined as 'doctors and other health professionals using medical means (medical technology, drugs, and so on) in a medical setting to fulfil the explicitly stated, prima facie non-medical wish of a patient'. Some instances of wish fulfilling medic...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2013-101480

    authors: Asscher EC,Schermer M

    更新日期:2014-12-01 00:00:00

  • Paediatric xenotransplantation clinical trials and the right to withdraw.

    abstract::Clinical trials of xenotransplantation (XTx) may begin early in the next decade, with kidneys from genetically modified pigs transplanted into adult humans. If successful, transplanting pig hearts into children with advanced heart failure may be the next step. Typically, clinical trials have a specified end date, and ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2019-105668

    authors: Hurst DJ,Padilla LA,Walters W,Hunter JM,Cooper DKC,Eckhoff DM,Cleveland D,Paris W

    更新日期:2020-05-01 00:00:00

  • Good medical ethics.

    abstract::This paper summarises the features of my paper, 'Voluntary Active Euthanasia', and a later jointly authored paper, 'Moral Fictions', which I believe are examples of good medical ethics. ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2014-102293

    authors: Brock DW

    更新日期:2015-01-01 00:00:00

  • 'If you pay, we'll operate immediately'.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:To study the attitudes of health care staff in four postcommunist countries towards taking gifts from their clients--and their confessed experience of actually taking such gifts. DESIGN:Survey questionnaire administered to officials including health care staff, supplemented by focus-group discussions with t...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.26.5.305

    authors: Miller WL,Grødeland AB,Koshechkina TY

    更新日期:2000-10-01 00:00:00

  • The case for a duty to research: not yet proven.

    abstract::In this commentary on 'Why participating in (certain) scientific research is a moral duty', I take issue with a number of Stjernschantz Forsberg et al's claims. Though abiding by the terms of a contract might be obligatory, this won't show that those terms themselves indicate a duty--even allowing that there's a contr...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 评论,杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2013-101370

    authors: Brassington I

    更新日期:2014-05-01 00:00:00

  • Covert video surveillance: the Staffordshire Protocol--a response to Dr Shinebourne.

    abstract::This paper is a response to Dr Shinebourne's response to my recent paper assessing the relative merits of the Staffordshire Protocol on covert video surveillance. Dr Shinebourne does not take the opportunity to rebut the criticisms made of the text of the protocol. It is further suggested that judicial oversight of th...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 评论,杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.22.6.349

    authors: Thomas T

    更新日期:1996-12-01 00:00:00

  • The gift of blood in Europe: an ethical defence of EC directive 89/381.

    abstract::Article 3.4 of EC directive 89/381 requires member states to take "all necessary measures to promote Community self-sufficiency in human blood or human plasma" and, for this purpose, to "encourage the voluntary unpaid donation of blood and plasma". This paper presents an ethical case in support of the policy of volunt...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.23.2.96

    authors: Keown J

    更新日期:1997-04-01 00:00:00

  • Treatment-resistant depression and physician-assisted death.

    abstract::In a recent article, Udo Schuklenk and Suzanne van de Vathorst argued in favour of a legal option of physician-assisted death for patients with 'treatment-resistant' depression. In this commentary, I contend that their argument neglects the important consideration of the professional integrity of physicians. In light ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 评论,杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2015-103060

    authors: MIller FG

    更新日期:2015-11-01 00:00:00

  • Opinions of private medical practitioners in Bloemfontein, South Africa, regarding euthanasia of terminally ill patients.

    abstract::The aim of this study was to determine the opinions of private medical practitioners in Bloemfontein, South Africa, regarding euthanasia of terminally ill patients. This descriptive study was performed amongst a simple random sample of 100 of 230 private medical practitioners in Bloemfontein. Information was obtained ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2008.027417

    authors: Brits L,Human L,Pieterse L,Sonnekus P,Joubert G

    更新日期:2009-03-01 00:00:00

  • Towards a bioethics of innovation.

    abstract::In recent years, it has become almost axiomatic that biomedical research and clinical practice should be 'innovative'-that is, that they should be always evolving and directed towards the production, translation and implementation of new technologies and practices. While this drive towards innovation in biomedicine mi...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2015-103048

    authors: Lipworth W,Axler R

    更新日期:2016-07-01 00:00:00

  • Response to: 'Why medical professionals have no moral claim to conscientious objection accommodation in liberal democracies' by Schuklenk and Smalling.

    abstract::The recent essay by Schuklenk and Smalling opposing respect for physicians' conscientious objections to providing patients with medical services that are legally permitted in liberal democracies is based on several erroneous assumptions. Acting in this manner would have serious harmful effects on the ethos of medicine...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 评论,杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2016-103670

    authors: Glick SM,Jotkowitz A

    更新日期:2017-04-01 00:00:00

  • Meaningful futility: requests for resuscitation against medical recommendation.

    abstract::'Futility' is a contentious term that has eluded clear definition, with proposed descriptions either too strict or too vague to encompass the many facets of medical care. Requests for futile care are often surrogates for requests of a more existential character, covering the whole range of personal, emotional, cultura...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2020-106232

    authors: Vivas L,Carpenter T

    更新日期:2020-04-24 00:00:00

  • Tell me what's wrong with me: a discourse analysis approach to the concept of patient autonomy.

    abstract:BACKGROUND:Patient autonomy has gradually replaced physician paternalism as an ethical ideal. However, in a medical context, the principle of individual autonomy has different meanings. More knowledge is needed about what is and should be an appropriate understanding of the concept of patient autonomy in clinical pract...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.24.6.394

    authors: Nessa J,Malterud K

    更新日期:1998-12-01 00:00:00

  • A comparison of journal instructions regarding institutional review board approval and conflict-of-interest disclosure between 1995 and 2005.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:To compare 2005 and 1995 ethics guidelines from journal editors to authors regarding requirements for institutional review board (IRB) approval and conflict-of-interest (COI) disclosure. DESIGN:A descriptive study of the ethics guidelines published in 103 English-language biomedical journals listed in the A...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2008.024299

    authors: Rowan-Legg A,Weijer C,Gao J,Fernandez C

    更新日期:2009-01-01 00:00:00