Analogy in moral deliberation: the role of imagination and theory in ethics.

Abstract:

:This paper develops themes addressed in an article by Eric Wiland in the Journal of Medical Ethics 2000;26:466-8, where he aims to contribute to the debate concerning the moral status of abortion, and to emphasise the importance of analogies in moral argument. In the present paper I try to secure more firmly a novel understanding of why analogy is an essential component in the attempt to justify moral beliefs. I seek to show how analogical argument both encapsulates and exercises the notions of rationality and imagination and that the construction, development, and comparison of analogies fundamentally underpins ethical argument. In so doing, it enables us to adopt imaginative and ethically illuminating perspectives but in a manner that does not relinquish any claims to intellectual rigour. I present a critique of a brand of "moral particularism" by showing how it cannot, if construed in a certain way, adequately conceive of how we use analogies and imaginary cases in ethics. Although such a particularism is thus impotent with regard to ethical debate, I show that the wider motivation behind particularism that can be extracted is of clear relevance and importance to medical practitioners.

journal_name

J Med Ethics

authors

Smith B

doi

10.1136/jme.28.4.244

keywords:

subject

Has Abstract

pub_date

2002-08-01 00:00:00

pages

244-8

issue

4

eissn

0306-6800

issn

1473-4257

journal_volume

28

pub_type

评论,杂志文章
  • Publish or be damned: Individual Funding Requests and the publicity condition.

    abstract::Many jurisdictions have processes to consider Individual Funding Requests but, with few exceptions, the decisions made with respect to these are not made public. Drawing upon Daniels and Sabin's account of the requirements of procedural justice, Accountability for Reasonableness, this paper considers several arguments...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2013-101578

    authors: Jonas M,Kolbe A,Warin B

    更新日期:2014-12-01 00:00:00

  • Procedural safeguards cannot disentangle MAiD from organ donation decisions.

    abstract::In the past, a vast majority of medical assistance in dying (MAiD) patients were elderly patients with cancer who are not suitable for organ donation, making organ donation from such patients a rare event. However, more expansive criteria for MAiD combined with an increased participation of MAiD patients in organ dona...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2020-106456

    authors: Buturovic Z

    更新日期:2020-12-10 00:00:00

  • A quiet revolution in organ transplant ethics.

    abstract::A quiet revolution is occurring in the field of transplantation. Traditionally, transplants have involved solid organs such as the kidney, heart and liver which are transplanted to prevent recipients from dying. Now transplants are being done of the face, hand, uterus, penis and larynx that aim at improving a recipien...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2015-103348

    authors: Caplan A,Purves D

    更新日期:2017-11-01 00:00:00

  • Why patients should keep their own records.

    abstract::Too many people now have access to confidential medical information. Patients are becoming justifiably wary and the doctor-patient relationship is deteriorating. We can avert the developing crisis by allowing patients to keep their own medical records at home. This will ensure that confidentiality is respected and tha...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.10.1.27

    authors: Coleman V

    更新日期:1984-03-01 00:00:00

  • What is the role of clinical ethics support in the era of e-medicine?

    abstract::The internet is becoming increasingly important in health care practice. The number of health-related web sites is rising exponentially as people seek health-related information and services to supplement traditional sources, such as their local doctor, friends, or family. The development of e-medicine poses important...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.27.suppl_1.i33

    authors: Parker M,Gray JA

    更新日期:2001-04-01 00:00:00

  • When they believe in miracles.

    abstract::Brierley et al argue that in cases where it is medically futile to continue providing life-sustaining therapies to children in intensive care, medical professionals should be allowed to withdraw such therapies, even when the parents of these children believe that there is a chance of a miracle cure taking place. In re...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 评论,杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2012-100677

    authors: Clarke S

    更新日期:2013-09-01 00:00:00

  • The great slippery-slope argument.

    abstract::Whenever some form of beneficent killing--for example, voluntary euthanasia--is advocated, the proposal is greeted with a flood of slippery-slope arguments warning of the dangers of a Nazi-style slide into genocide. This paper is an attempt systematically to evaluate arguments of this kind. Although there are slippery...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.19.3.169

    authors: Burgess JA

    更新日期:1993-09-01 00:00:00

  • How medical ethical principles are applied in treatment with artificial insemination by donors (AID) in Hunan, China: effective practice at the Reproductive and Genetic Hospital of CITIC-Xiangya.

    abstract::This paper investigates the efficiency of application of medical ethics principles in the practice of artificial insemination by donors (AID) in China, in a culture characterised by traditional ethical values and disapproval of AID. The paper presents the ethical approach to AID treatment as established by the Reprodu...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2004.007831

    authors: Li LJ,Lu GX

    更新日期:2005-06-01 00:00:00

  • 'I just need an opiate refill to get me through the weekend'.

    abstract::In this article, we discuss the ethical dimensions for the prescribing behaviours of opioids for a chronic pain patient, a scenario commonly witnessed by many physicians. The opioid epidemic in the USA and Canada is well known, existing since the late 1990s, and individuals are suffering and dying as a result of the e...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2018-105099

    authors: Yan E,Kuo DJ

    更新日期:2019-04-01 00:00:00

  • "Allow natural death" versus "do not resuscitate": three words that can change a life.

    abstract::Physician-written "do not resuscitate" DNR orders elicit negative reactions from stakeholders that may decrease appropriate end-of-life care. The semantic significance of the phrase has led to a proposed replacement of DNR with "allow natural death" (AND). Prior to this investigation, no scientific papers address the ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2006.018317

    authors: Venneman SS,Narnor-Harris P,Perish M,Hamilton M

    更新日期:2008-01-01 00:00:00

  • Should doctors strike?

    abstract::Last year in June, British doctors went on strike for the first time since 1975. Amidst a global economic downturn and with many health systems struggling with reduced finances, around the world the issue of public health workers going on strike is a very real one. Almost all doctors will agree that we should always f...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2013-101397

    authors: Park JJ,Murray SA

    更新日期:2014-05-01 00:00:00

  • Participation in biomedical research is an imperfect moral duty: a response to John Harris.

    abstract::In his paper "Scientific research is a moral duty", John Harris argues that individuals have a moral duty to participate in biomedical research by volunteering as research subjects. He supports his claim with reference to what he calls the principle of beneficence as embodied in the "rule of rescue" (the moral obligat...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 评论,杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2006.017384

    authors: Shapshay S,Pimple KD

    更新日期:2007-07-01 00:00:00

  • Routine antenatal HIV testing and informed consent: an unworkable marriage?

    abstract::This paper considers the ethics of routine antenatal HIV testing and the role of informed consent within such a policy in order to decide how we should proceed in this area--a decision that ultimately rests on the relative importance we give to public health goals on the one hand and respect for individual autonomy on...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2006.018861

    authors: Bennett R

    更新日期:2007-08-01 00:00:00

  • The demise of UKXIRA and the regulation of solid-organ xenotransplantation in the UK.

    abstract::The new regulations on xenotransplantation pay insufficient attention to the broad ethical (and legal) problems raised by this technique and that the abandonment of a national body with overall regulatory authority in this area is a mistake. ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 社论,评审

    doi:10.1136/jme.2007.020768

    authors: McLean S,Williamson L

    更新日期:2007-07-01 00:00:00

  • The premature breech: caesarean section or trial of labour?

    abstract::Obstetricians face difficult decisions when the interests of fetus and mother conflict. An example is the problem of choosing the delivery method when labour begins prematurely and the fetus is breech. Vaginal delivery involves risks for the breech fetus of brain damage or death caused by umbilical cord compression an...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章,评审

    doi:10.1136/jme.14.1.18

    authors: Anderson G,Strong C

    更新日期:1988-03-01 00:00:00

  • Sustainability principle for the ethics of healthcare resource allocation.

    abstract::We propose a principle of sustainability to complement established principles used for justifying healthcare resource allocation. We argue that the application of established principles of equal treatment, need, prognosis and cost-effectiveness gives rise to what we call negative dynamics: a gradual depletion of the v...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2020-106644

    authors: Munthe C,Fumagalli D,Malmqvist E

    更新日期:2021-02-01 00:00:00

  • Perimortem gamete retrieval: should we worry about consent?

    abstract::Perimortem gamete retrieval has been a possibility for several decades. It involves the surgical extraction of gametes which can then be cryo-preserved and stored for future use. Usually, the request for perimortem gamete retrieval is made by the patient's partner after the patient himself, or herself, has lost the ca...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2013-101727

    authors: Smajdor A

    更新日期:2015-06-01 00:00:00

  • Limits of trust in medical AI.

    abstract::Artificial intelligence (AI) is expected to revolutionise the practice of medicine. Recent advancements in the field of deep learning have demonstrated success in variety of clinical tasks: detecting diabetic retinopathy from images, predicting hospital readmissions, aiding in the discovery of new drugs, etc. AI's pro...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2019-105935

    authors: Hatherley JJ

    更新日期:2020-07-01 00:00:00

  • Scientific misconduct from the perspective of research coordinators: a national survey.

    abstract:OBJECTIVE:To report results from a national survey of coordinators and managers of clinical research studies in the US on their perceptions of and experiences with scientific misconduct. METHODS:Data were collected using the Scientific Misconduct Questionnaire-Revised. Eligible responses were received from 1645 of 530...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2006.016394

    authors: Pryor ER,Habermann B,Broome ME

    更新日期:2007-06-01 00:00:00

  • Assessing research risks systematically: the net risks test.

    abstract::Dual-track assessment directs research ethics committees (RECs) to assess the risks of research interventions based on the unclear distinction between therapeutic and non-therapeutic interventions. The net risks test, in contrast, relies on the clinically familiar method of assessing the risks and benefits of interven...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2005.014043

    authors: Wendler D,Miller FG

    更新日期:2007-08-01 00:00:00

  • Literature and medicine.

    abstract::There are various ways in which medicine and literature interact, but this paper concentrates on the contribution which literature can make to 'whole person understanding'. Scientific understanding is concerned with seeing events and actions in terms of patterns or similarities. But 'whole person understanding' is con...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.17.2.93

    authors: Downie RS

    更新日期:1991-06-01 00:00:00

  • Evidence of broad-based family support for the use of archival childhood tumour samples in future research.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:This study aimed to determine the ability to successfully contact past paediatric patients and their families to request participation in research, to assess familial views on the use of previously collected archival clinical samples for research purposes, and to highlight the ethical and practical issues in...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2015-103141

    authors: Sexton-Oates A,Dodgshun A,MacGregor D,Ludlow LE,Sullivan M,Saffery R

    更新日期:2016-07-01 00:00:00

  • Defending the four principles approach as a good basis for good medical practice and therefore for good medical ethics.

    abstract::This paper argues that the four prima facie principles-beneficence, non-maleficence, respect for autonomy and justice-afford a good and widely acceptable basis for 'doing good medical ethics'. It confronts objections that the approach is simplistic, incompatible with a virtue-based approach to medicine, that it requir...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2014-102282

    authors: Gillon R

    更新日期:2015-01-01 00:00:00

  • Value judgements in the decision-making process for the elderly patient.

    abstract::The question of whether old age should or should not play a role in medical decision-making for the elderly patient is regularly debated in ethics and medicine. In this paper we investigate exactly how age influences the decision-making process. To explore the normative argumentation in the decisions regarding an elde...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2008.025247

    authors: Ubachs-Moust J,Houtepen R,Vos R,ter Meulen R

    更新日期:2008-12-01 00:00:00

  • The ethics and politics of mindfulness-based interventions.

    abstract::Recently, there has been a lot of enthusiasm for mindfulness practice and its use in healthcare, businesses and schools. An increasing number of studies give us ground for cautious optimism about the potential of mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) to improve people's lives across a number of dimensions. This paper...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2015-102942

    authors: Schmidt AT

    更新日期:2016-07-01 00:00:00

  • Views regarding the training of ethics consultants: a survey of physicians caring for patients in ICU.

    abstract:BACKGROUND:Despite the expansion of ethics consultation services, questions remain about the aims of clinical ethics consultation, its methods and the expertise of those who provide such services. OBJECTIVE:To describe physicians' expectations regarding the training and skills necessary for ethics consultants to contr...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.2006.016287

    authors: Chwang E,Landy DC,Sharp RR

    更新日期:2007-06-01 00:00:00

  • True and false concerns about neuroenhancement: a response to 'Neuroenhancers, addiction and research ethics', by D M Shaw.

    abstract::In his critical comment on our paper in this journal, Shaw argues that 'false assumptions' which we have criticised are in fact correct ('Neuroenhancers, addiction and research ethics'). He suggests that the risk of addiction to neuroenhancers may not be relevant, and that safety and research in regard to neuroenhance...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 评论,杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2013-101317

    authors: Heinz A,Kipke R,Müller S,Wiesing U

    更新日期:2014-04-01 00:00:00

  • Family presence during cardiopulmonary resuscitation: who should decide?

    abstract::Whether to allow the presence of family members during cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) has been a highly contentious topic in recent years. Even though a great deal of evidence and professional guidelines support the option of family presence during resuscitation (FPDR), many healthcare professionals still oppose ...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/medethics-2012-100715

    authors: Lederman Z,Garasic M,Piperberg M

    更新日期:2014-05-01 00:00:00

  • Dealing with the brain-damaged old--dignity before sanctity.

    abstract::The present and future rapid increase in the hospital population of geriatric patients is discussed with particular reference to the problem of advanced brain degeneration. The consequences of various clinical management options are outlined and it is suggested that extreme attempts either to preserve or terminate lif...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.8.4.173

    authors: Robertson GS

    更新日期:1982-12-01 00:00:00

  • Comments on an obstructed death -- a case conference revisited: commentary 1.

    abstract::The paper comments on Scott Dunbar's "An obstructed death and medical ethics," arguing contra Dunbar that we should not view truth-telling to the terminally ill as primarily governed by principles of veracity and respect for autonomy. All such rules are of limited value in medical ethics. We should instead turn to a...

    journal_title:Journal of medical ethics

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1136/jme.16.2.88

    authors: Byrne P

    更新日期:1990-06-01 00:00:00