当前位置： SCI文献检索 > Journal of Surgical Education期刊下所有文献 > Individualised Expert Feedback is Not Essential for Improving Basic Clinical Skills Performance in Novice Learners: A Randomized Trial.

Individualised Expert Feedback is Not Essential for Improving Basic Clinical Skills Performance in Novice Learners: A Randomized Trial.

Abstract：

OBJECTIVE:To determine whether unsupervised video feedback (UVF) is as effective as direct expert feedback (DEF) in improving clinical skills performance for medical students learning basic surgical skills-intravenous cannulation, catheterization, and suturing. BACKGROUND:Feedback is a vital component of the learning process, yet great variation persists in its quality, quantity, and methods of delivery. The use of video technology to assist in the provision of feedback has been adopted increasingly. METHODS:A prospective, blinded randomized trial comparing DEF, an expert reviewing students' performances with subsequent improvement suggestions, and UVF, students reviewing their own performance with an expert teaching video, was carried out. Medical students received an initial teaching lecture on intravenous cannulation, catheterization, and suturing and were then recorded performing the task. They subsequently received either DEF or UVF before reperforming the task. Students' recordings were additionally scored by 2 blinded experts using a validated proforma. RESULTS:A total of 71 medical students were recruited. Cannulation scores improved 4.3% with DEF and 9.5% with UVF (p = 0.044), catheterization scores improved 8.7% with DEF and 8.9% with UVF (p = 0.96), and suturing improved 15.6% with DEF and 13.2% with UVF (p = 0.54). Improvement from baseline scores was significant in all cases (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION:Video-assisted feedback allows a significant improvement in clinical skills for novices. No significant additional benefit was demonstrated from DEF, and a similar improvement can be obtained using a generic expert video and allowing students to review their own performance. This could have significant implications for the design and delivery of such training.

journal_name

J Surg Educ

journal_title

Journal of surgical education

authors

Phillips AW,Matthan J,Bookless LR,Whitehead IJ,Madhavan A,Rodham P,Porter ALR,Nesbitt CI,Stansby G

doi

10.1016/j.jsurg.2016.12.003

subject

Has Abstract

pub_date

2017-01-01 00:00:00

pages

612-620

issue

4

eissn

1931-7204

issn

1878-7452

pii

S1931-7204(16)30199-4

journal_volume

74

pub_type

杂志文章,随机对照试验

相关文献

Journal of Surgical Education文献大全
  • Objective Assessment of the Entrustable Professional Activity Handover in Undergraduate and Postgraduate Surgical Learners.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:This study used a virtual patient simulation (VPS) to quantifiably and objectively assess undergraduate (UG) to postgraduate (PG) medical learners' acquisition of the entrustable professional activity (EPA) "handover," focusing particularly on the transition to residency. This EPA is critical because it is pa...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2019.03.008

    authors： Posel N,Hoover ML,Bergman S,Grushka J,Rosenzveig A,Fleiszer D

    更新日期：2019-01-01 00:00:00

  • Training and Assessment of Hysteroscopic Skills: A Systematic Review.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:The aim of this systematic review was to identify studies on hysteroscopic training and assessment. DESIGN:PubMed, Excerpta Medica, the Cochrane Library, and Web of Science were searched in January 2015. Manual screening of references and citation tracking were also performed. Studies on hysteroscopic educat...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章,评审

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2016.04.006

    authors： Savran MM,Sørensen SM,Konge L,Tolsgaard MG,Bjerrum F

    更新日期：2016-09-01 00:00:00

  • A Randomized Cross-Over Trial Focused on Clinical Breast Exam Skill Acquisition Using High Fidelity versus Low Fidelity Simulation Models in Rwanda.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Breast cancer incidence is rising for women in low and middle income country (LMIC)s. Growing the health care workforce trained in clinical breast exam (CBE) is critical to mitigating breast cancer globally. We developed a CBE simulation training course and determined whether training on a low-fidelity (LF) s...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.02.030

    authors： Murthy SS,Ntakiyiruta G,Ntirenganya F,Ingabire A,Defregger SK,Reznor G,Lipitz S,Troyan SL,Raza S,Dunnington G,Riviello R

    更新日期：2020-01-01 00:00:00

  • Qualitative Analysis of Effective Teamwork in the Operating Room (OR).

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:To conduct focus group interviews with operating room (OR) personnel to determine components of effective teamwork to inform a revision of a teamwork assessment instrument. DESIGN:Qualitative research study targeting OR personnel using semi-structured focus group interviews of interprofessional OR personnel....

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.09.019

    authors： Paige JT,Garbee DD,Bonanno LS,Kerdolff KE

    更新日期：2020-11-04 00:00:00

  • An In-Depth Analysis of Research Output in Successful Integrated Plastic Surgery Match Applicants and Factors Associated With Matching at Top-Ranked Programs.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:With USMLE Step I score reports becoming pass/fail, research output may become a more important factor for applicants in the integrated plastic surgery match. The authors aim to assess the research output of successful applicants and bibliometric variables associated with matching at higher tier programs. DE...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.06.026

    authors： Mellia JA,Jou C,Rathi S,Perzia BM,Morel A,Azoury SC,Fischer JP

    更新日期：2021-01-01 00:00:00

  • Desktop-based computer-assisted orthopedic training system for spinal surgery.

    abstract：BACKGROUND:Simulation and surgical training has moved on since its inception during the end of the last century. The trainees are getting more exposed to computers and laboratory training in different subspecialties. More needs to be done in orthopedic simulation in spinal surgery. AIMS:To develop a training system fo...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2014.04.012

    authors： Rambani R,Ward J,Viant W

    更新日期：2014-11-01 00:00:00

  • Suture end length as a function of knot integrity.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:To evaluate tension at the failure of 3 commonly used sutures when suture ends were cut to 3 lengths. STUDY DESIGN:Knots were tied using U.S. Pharmacopeia Size 0-0 polyglactin 910, silk, or polydioxanone sutures. The knots were tied randomly on a jig by the same surgeon. End lengths were then cut to random l...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2009.10.003

    authors： Muffly TM,Cook C,Distasio J,Bonham AJ,Blandon RE

    更新日期：2009-09-01 00:00:00

  • Minimum number of throws needed for knot security.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:The purpose of the study was to determine the optimal number of throws to ensure knot security. STUDY DESIGN:Knots were tied with 3, 4, 5, or 6 square throws with 0-gauge coated polyester, polydioxanone, polypropylene, and polyglactin 910. The suture was soaked in 0.9% sodium chloride and subsequently transf...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2010.11.001

    authors： Muffly TM,Kow N,Iqbal I,Barber MD

    更新日期：2011-03-01 00:00:00

  • Predictors of Undergraduate and Postgraduate Clinical Performance: A Longitudinal Cohort Study.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Though many medical schools applied various admission criteria in the selection process, the evidence of using those criteria is unclear. This study examined the predictive validity of each admission criterion for student competency. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS:We conducted a prospective cohort study o...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2016.03.006

    authors： Kim T,Chang JY,Myung SJ,Chang Y,Park KD,Park WB,Shin CS

    更新日期：2016-07-01 00:00:00

  • Nomogram to predict successful placement in surgical subspecialty fellowships using applicant characteristics.

    abstract：PURPOSE:The purpose of the study was to develop a model that predicts an individual applicant's probability of successful placement into a surgical subspecialty fellowship program. METHODS:Candidates who applied to surgical fellowships during a 3-year period were identified in a set of databases that included the elec...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2011.11.006

    authors： Muffly TM,Barber MD,Karafa MT,Kattan MW,Shniter A,Jelovsek JE

    更新日期：2012-05-01 00:00:00

  • An experience in surgical anatomy to provide first-year medical students with an early exposure to general surgery: a pilot study.

    abstract：INTRODUCTION:The level of interest expressed by medical students toward the field of general surgery has decreased. The aims of this study were to (1) describe an educational scheme in surgical anatomy that increases interaction between practicing surgeons and first-year medical students and (2) garner feedback and opi...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2009.04.005

    authors： Are C,Stoddard HA,Northam LC,Thompson JS,Todd GL

    更新日期：2009-07-01 00:00:00

  • Do international rotations make surgical residents more resource-efficient? A preliminary study.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Interest in international surgery among general surgery residents in the United States has been shown in several publications. Several general surgery residency programs have reported their experiences with international surgery rotations (ISRs). Learning to use limited resources more efficiently is often cit...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2011.10.009

    authors： Oliphant JL,Ruhlandt RR,Sherman SR,Schlatter MG,Green JA

    更新日期：2012-05-01 00:00:00

  • Giant colonic diverticulum: an unusual abdominal lump.

    abstract：:Giant colonic diverticulum is a rare complication of diverticular disease of the colon and is thought to result, in most cases, from a "ball-valve" effect. The presentation and clinical course can be variable and confusing. The most common symptoms are abdominal pain and a palpable abdominal lump, with many patients p...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章,评审

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2006.10.007

    authors： Praveen BV,Suraparaju L,Jaunoo SS,Tang T,Walsh SR,Ogunbiyi OA

    更新日期：2007-03-01 00:00:00

  • Trauma and Orthopedic Surgery Curriculum Concordance: An Operative Learning Curve Trajectory Perspective.

    abstract：INTRODUCTION:Certification of completion of training in Trauma and Orthopedic (T&O) surgery in the UK requires the demonstration of operative competence in 12 index procedures, achieved through attaining a level 4 consultant-validated procedure-based assessment (PBA). The aim of this study was to evaluate the trajector...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2019.05.009

    authors： Hopkins L,Robinson DBT,Brown C,Egan R,Iorwerth A,Holt M,Lewis WG

    更新日期：2019-01-01 00:00:00

  • Service versus education, what are we talking about?

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:To investigate the degree of variability in perception as related to the service versus education issue in general surgery residency education. STUDY DESIGN:A survey questionnaire was designed with 15 scenarios constructed by the author to represent an array of resident experiences with differing educational...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2011.11.007

    authors： Smith DE,Johnson B,Jones Y

    更新日期：2012-05-01 00:00:00

  • Student Views on the Use of 2 Styles of Video-Enhanced Feedback Compared to Standard Lecture Feedback During Clinical Skills Training.

    abstract：BACKGROUND:Feedback plays an important role in the learning process. However, often this may be delivered in an unstructured fashion that can detract from its potential benefit. Further, students may have different preferences in how feedback should be delivered, which may be influenced by which method they feel will l...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章,随机对照试验

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2015.04.017

    authors： Nesbitt C,Phillips AW,Searle R,Stansby G

    更新日期：2015-09-01 00:00:00

  • Cold injury in the United States military population: current trends and comparison with past conflicts.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:The war in Afghanistan represents the first large-scale conflict involving military troops in a cold, mountainous climate since the Korean War. An analysis was conducted to identify the extent of cold weather injuries, especially frostbite, in the deployed military population. DESIGN:A retrospective analysis...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2010.02.003

    authors： Hall A,Evans K,Pribyl S

    更新日期：2010-03-01 00:00:00

  • Anatomy by Whole Body Dissection as an Elective: Student Outcomes.

    abstract：BACKGROUND:Anatomy education has long been considered fundamental to the medical profession. Recently, Australasian medical schools have favored prosected human material, models and medical imaging in their anatomy curriculum with only 3 medical schools offering whole-body dissection. The aim of this study was to explo...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.07.041

    authors： Huynh N,Burgess A,Wing L,Mellis C

    更新日期：2020-09-18 00:00:00

  • Comparison of surgical residency applicants from U.S. medical schools with U.S.-born and foreign-born international medical school graduates.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Compare characteristics of U.S. medical school graduates with U.S.-born and foreign-born international medical school (IMG) graduates. DESIGN:Retrospective analysis. SETTING:East Carolina University, a tertiary care teaching hospital. PARTICIPANTS:Demographic data, United States Medical Licensing Examinati...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2008.05.002

    authors： Schenarts PJ,Love KM,Agle SC,Haisch CE

    更新日期：2008-11-01 00:00:00

  • Piloting a medical student observational experience with hospital-based trauma chaplains.

    abstract：INTRODUCTION:Medical students have typically received relatively modest training in approaches for engaging the concerns of patients and families facing life-threatening situations and terminal illnesses. We propose that medical students would perceive benefits to their communication skills, understanding of the role o...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2013.07.001

    authors： Perechocky A,DeLisser H,Ciampa R,Browning J,Shea JA,Corcoran AM

    更新日期：2014-01-01 00:00:00

  • Transition to Residency: The Successful Development and Implementation of a Nonclinical Elective in Perioperative Management.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Few medical school programs in Canada address challenges related to the significant increase in responsibility for patient care between medical school and residency. This is particularly important in surgery and anesthesia due to the high-acuity care required during the perioperative period. The purpose of th...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2017.08.022

    authors： McDonald H,Gawad N,Raîche I,Rubens FD

    更新日期：2018-01-01 00:00:00

  • Changing Education Paradigms: Training Transplant Fellows for High Stake Procedures.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Living kidney donation is a unique operation, as healthy patients are placed at risks inherent with major surgery without physical benefit. The ethical implications associated with any morbidity make it a high-stakes procedure. Fellowships are faced with the dilemma of optimizing fellow training in this deman...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.01.005

    authors： Rice TC,Kassam AF,Lewis HV,Hobeika M,Cuffy MC,Ratner LE,Diwan TS

    更新日期：2020-01-01 00:00:00

  • Acute Workplace Hazards in Orthopedic Surgery: Resident Survey Regarding Splash and Workplace Violence Events.

    abstract：INTRODUCTION:Orthopedic surgery residents are at risk for daily work-related hazards and exposures. Hazards related specific to this specialty includes radiation exposure, smoke inhalation (from electrocautery), and disease transmission through contact with surgical instruments or sharps during procedures. However, min...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.05.007

    authors： Yohe N,Swiggett SJ,Razi A,Bowman JR,Watson SL,Pearson JM,Hudson PW,Patt JC,Ames SE,Leddy LR,Khoury JG,Tubb CC,McGwin G,Ponce B

    更新日期：2020-01-01 00:00:00

  • Novel educational approach for medical students: improved retention rates using interactive medical software compared with traditional lecture-based format.

    abstract：BACKGROUND:Mannequin and computer-based simulators are useful for the practice of patient management, physical procedures, and competency. However, they are ineffective in teaching clinical medicine. StepStone Interactive Medical Software (SS) is a web-based medical learning modality that provides the user with a highl...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章,随机对照试验

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2012.05.013

    authors： Subramanian A,Timberlake M,Mittakanti H,Lara M,Brandt ML

    更新日期：2012-07-01 00:00:00

  • Identifying Managerial Roles of General Surgery Coordinators: Making the Case for Utilization of a Standardized Job Description Framework.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Residency coordinators are valuable members of the education leadership administration. In General Surgery, program directors must devote time to both their clinical practice and as the leader of the education program for surgical residents. With the introduction of competencies and the Next Accreditation Sys...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2018.07.003

    authors： Nickel BL,Roof J,Dolejs S,Choi JN,Torbeck L

    更新日期：2018-11-01 00:00:00

  • Developing a comprehensive resident education evaluation system in the era of milestone assessment.

    abstract：OBJECTIVES:In an effort to move training programs toward competency-based education, the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) introduced the Next Accreditation System (NAS), which organizes specific milestones regarding resident skills, knowledge, and abilities along a continuum. In order to fos...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2014.12.007

    authors： Gardner AK,Scott DJ,Choti MA,Mansour JC

    更新日期：2015-07-01 00:00:00

  • Entrustable Professional Activities in General Surgery: Trends in Resident Self-Assessment.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:Effective self-assessment is a cornerstone of lifelong professional development; however, evidence suggests physicians have a limited ability to self-assess. Novel strategies to improve the accuracy of learner self-assessment are needed. Our institution's surgical entrustable professional activity (EPA) imple...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.05.005

    authors： Stahl CC,Jung SA,Rosser AA,Kraut AS,Schnapp BH,Westergaard M,Hamedani AG,Minter RM,Greenberg JA

    更新日期：2020-01-01 00:00:00

  • Smart(phone) Learning Experience Among Vascular Trainees Using a Response System Application.

    abstract：OBJECTIVES:Smartphones have become the most important personal technological device. M-learning is learning through mobile device educational technology. We aim to assess the acceptability of a smartphone learning experience among the vascular trainees and determine if results could inform formal teaching efforts. MET...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2016.12.006

    authors： Al-Jundi W,Kayssi A,Papia G,Dueck A

    更新日期：2017-01-01 00:00:00

  • Faculty Emotional Intelligence Matters for Resident Education.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:This study aimed to determine the emotional intelligence (EI) of surgical faculty and evaluate its relationship with resident evaluations of faculty behaviors. DESIGN:This study retrospectively collected faculty EI scores as well as general surgery resident evaluations of faculty. Parametric and nonparametri...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.03.019

    authors： Weis HB,Pickett ML,Weis JJ,Dorsey O,Bailey LW,Gardner AK,Napier R,AbdelFattah KR

    更新日期：2020-01-01 00:00:00

  • Development of the User Experience (UX) and Video Quality Evaluation (VQE) Instruments for Assessment of Intraoperative Video Capture Technology.

    abstract：OBJECTIVE:There exists a lack of technology to reliably and routinely capture high-quality video of open surgical procedures. To critically evaluate and compare new and existing technology solutions, we must have widely accepted evaluation criteria for intraoperative camera devices. The objective, therefore, was to dev...

    journal_title：Journal of surgical education

    pub_type： 杂志文章

    doi：10.1016/j.jsurg.2020.06.011

    authors： Saun TJ,Grantcharov TP

    更新日期：2021-01-01 00:00:00