Does selection pay off? A cost-benefit comparison of medical school selection and lottery systems.

Abstract:

CONTEXT:Resources for medical education are becoming more constrained, whereas accountability in medical education is increasing. In this constrictive environment, medical schools need to consider and justify their selection procedures in terms of costs and benefits. To date, there have been no studies focusing on this aspect of selection. OBJECTIVES:We aimed to examine and compare the costs and benefits of two different approaches to admission into medical school: a tailored, multimethod selection process versus a lottery procedure. Our goal was to assess the relative effectiveness of each approach and to compare these in terms of benefits and costs from the perspective of the medical school. METHODS:The study was conducted at Maastricht University Medical School, at which the selection process and a weighted lottery procedure ran in parallel for 3 years (2011-2013). The costs and benefits of the selection process were compared with those of the lottery procedure over three student cohorts throughout the Bachelor's programme. The extra costs of selection represented the monetary investment of the medical school in conducting the selection procedure; the benefits were derived from the increase in income generated by the prevention of dropout and the reductions in extra costs facilitated by decreases in the repetition of blocks and objective structured clinical examinations. RESULTS:The tailor-made selection procedure cost about €139 000 when extrapolated to a full cohort of students (n = 286). The lottery procedure came with negligible costs for the medical school. However, the average benefits of selection compared with the lottery system added up to almost €207 000. CONCLUSIONS:This study not only shows that conducting a cost-benefit comparison is feasible in the context of selection for medical school, but also that an 'expensive' selection process can be cost-beneficial in comparison with an 'inexpensive' lottery system. We encourage other medical schools to examine the cost-effectiveness of their own selection processes in relation to student outcomes in order to extend knowledge on this important topic.

journal_name

Med Educ

journal_title

Medical education

authors

Schreurs S,Cleland J,Muijtjens AMM,Oude Egbrink MGA,Cleutjens K

doi

10.1111/medu.13698

subject

Has Abstract

pub_date

2018-12-01 00:00:00

pages

1240-1248

issue

12

eissn

0308-0110

issn

1365-2923

journal_volume

52

pub_type

杂志文章
  • Preparedness is not enough: understanding transitions as critically intensive learning periods.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:Doctors make many transitions whilst they are training and throughout their ensuing careers. Despite studies showing that transitions in other high-risk professions such as aviation have been linked to increased risk in the form of adverse outcomes, the effects of changes on doctors' performance and conseque...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2011.04048.x

    authors: Kilminster S,Zukas M,Quinton N,Roberts T

    更新日期:2011-10-01 00:00:00

  • Towards evidence-based practice in medical training: making evaluations more meaningful.

    abstract:CONTEXT:The evaluation of training is problematic and the evidence base inconclusive. This situation may arise for 2 main reasons: training is not understood as a complex intervention and, related to this, the evaluation methods applied are often overly simplistic. METHOD:This paper makes the case for construing train...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2929.2004.02021.x

    authors: Drescher U,Warren F,Norton K

    更新日期:2004-12-01 00:00:00

  • Dealing with death and dying.

    abstract::We instituted two thanatology seminars for medical students and residents which emphasized feelings more than objective data. The seminars began with students filling out a death certificate on themselves. Eighty-four per cent predicted that their own probable cause of death would be from an acute illness. Discussion ...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.1994.tb02533.x

    authors: McFarland KF,Rollins EC,Gonzalez MF,Rhoades DR

    更新日期:1994-03-01 00:00:00

  • Using job analysis to identify core and specific competencies: implications for selection and recruitment.

    abstract:OBJECTIVE:Modern postgraduate medical training requires both accurate and reliable selection procedures. An essential first step is to conduct detailed job analysis studies. This paper reports data on a series of job analyses to develop a competency model for three secondary care specialties (anaesthesia, obstetrics an...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章,多中心研究

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2008.03174.x

    authors: Patterson F,Ferguson E,Thomas S

    更新日期:2008-12-01 00:00:00

  • The medical school as a social organization: the sources of resistance to change.

    abstract::Medical schools vary by nation and by culture but, for students, the experience appears to be very similar. Also, despite a half-century of radical changes in medical practice, education as a process of socialization for the profession is relatively unchanged. At the same time, medical educators have frequently instit...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.1989.tb01538.x

    authors: Bloom SW

    更新日期:1989-05-01 00:00:00

  • Non-analytical models of clinical reasoning: the role of experience.

    abstract:OBJECTIVE:This paper aims to summarise the evidence supporting the role of experience-based, non-analytic reasoning (NAR) or pattern recognition as a central feature of expert medical diagnosis. METHODS:The authors examine a series of studies, primarily from their own research programme at McMaster University, that de...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章,评审

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2007.02914.x

    authors: Norman G,Young M,Brooks L

    更新日期:2007-12-01 00:00:00

  • Beyond the self: The role of co-regulation in medical students' self-regulated learning.

    abstract:CONTEXT:Medical students are expected to self-regulate their learning within complex and unpredictable clinical learning environments. Research increasingly focuses on the effects of social interactions on the development of self-regulation in workplace settings, a notion embodied within the concept of co-regulated lea...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/medu.14018

    authors: Bransen D,Govaerts MJB,Sluijsmans DMA,Driessen EW

    更新日期:2020-03-01 00:00:00

  • 'More shades of grey in my answers': an interview study revisiting attitude erosion during clerkships.

    abstract:CONTEXT:Small declines in patient-centred attitudes during medical education have caused great concern. Although some of the self-report scales applied have solid psychometric foundations, validity evidence for the interpretation of attitude erosion during clerkships remains weak. OBJECTIVES:We sought to address this ...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/medu.12102

    authors: Bombeke K,Symons L,Mortelmans D,Debaene L,Schol S,Van Royen P,De Winter B

    更新日期:2013-05-01 00:00:00

  • The value of student-made models as learning aids in physiology.

    abstract::In a new educational scheme introduced in Malta in 1978, university students spend half of the academic year studying and the other half as workers in various departments. During their work phase, students designed and made working models as teaching aids for the study of physiology. The value of these models was asse...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.1984.tb01277.x

    authors: Abu-Sitta SA,Shalaby MA,Hajek J

    更新日期:1984-09-01 00:00:00

  • Reliability of the clinical teaching effectiveness instrument.

    abstract:INTRODUCTION:The Clinical Teaching Effectiveness Instrument (CTEI) was developed to evaluate the quality of the clinical teaching of educators. Its authors reported evidence supporting content and criterion validity and found favourable reliability findings. We tested the validity and reliability of this instrument in ...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2929.2005.02245.x

    authors: van der Hem-Stokroos HH,van der Vleuten CP,Daelmans HE,Haarman HJ,Scherpbier AJ

    更新日期:2005-09-01 00:00:00

  • The professional attitudes of Nigerian first year medical students.

    abstract::In a study of the development of professional attitudes in medical students, a modified version of the Medical Attitudes Inventory (Harris, 1974) was administered to 141 male and female first year medical students in Lagos, Nigeria. The results show that the students have well-defined attitudes on certain issues and a...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.1978.tb01417.x

    authors: Jegede RO

    更新日期:1978-11-01 00:00:00

  • A comparison of the interviewing skills of first- and final-year medical students.

    abstract::This study compared the communication skills of randomly chosen first- and final-year medical students. The intention was to follow up previous research, conducted over 10 years ago, into the effects of the medical curriculum on communication skills. It was hypothesized that there would be little improvement in such s...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.1992.tb00203.x

    authors: Davis H,Nicholaou T

    更新日期:1992-11-01 00:00:00

  • To be and not to be: the paradox of the emerging professional stance.

    abstract:PURPOSE:Understanding how students resolve professional conflict is essential to teaching and evaluating professionalism. The purpose of this study was to refine an existing coding structure of rationalizations of student behaviour, and to further our understanding of students' reasoning strategies in the face of perce...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.2003.01326.x

    authors: Ginsburg S,Regehr G,Lingard L

    更新日期:2003-04-01 00:00:00

  • Sexual harassment during medical training: the perceptions of medical students at a university medical school in Australia.

    abstract:CONTEXT:A survey of medical students' experiences of sexual harassment during medical training. OBJECTIVE:To assess the prevalence and nature of workplace sexual harassment as perceived by undergraduate medical students in order to address their learning needs concerning setting and maintaining sexual boundaries. DES...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.2000.00684.x

    authors: White GE

    更新日期:2000-12-01 00:00:00

  • Analysing qualitative data: ethnography and the evaluation of medical education.

    abstract::Quantitative methods of evaluating the outcomes of medical education may not always deliver the information which course organizers and teachers most need in order to improve their courses. Qualitative methods of research could provide such information. However, the use of qualitative methods has been limited by the d...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.1989.tb01575.x

    authors: Walker M

    更新日期:1989-11-01 00:00:00

  • Teaching of neuroanatomy by means of self-instructional laboratory stations.

    abstract::Neuroanatomical laboratory material was presented to first-year medical students in a series of six self-instructional stations. Each station was designed to emphasize one major objective and to be completed without reference to any other station. Upon completion of a station the students filled out a response questio...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.1980.tb02623.x

    authors: Fisher LJ,Davis WK,Hitch EJ,Barr PA

    更新日期:1980-03-01 00:00:00

  • Using simulated patients to develop doctors' skills in facilitating behaviour change: addressing childhood obesity.

    abstract:OBJECTIVES:This study aimed to describe the application, feasibility and outcomes of using simulated patients (SPs) to increase the skills of general practitioners (GPs) delivering a behavioural intervention to reduce childhood overweight and mild obesity. METHODS:Five female actors were trained as SPs. A total of 67 ...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2010.03686.x

    authors: Gerner B,Sanci L,Cahill H,Ukoumunne OC,Gold L,Rogers L,McCallum Z,Wake M

    更新日期:2010-07-01 00:00:00

  • Predictive validity of the multiple mini-interview for selecting medical trainees.

    abstract:INTRODUCTION:In this paper we report on further tests of the validity of the multiple mini-interview (MMI) selection process, comparing MMI scores with those achieved on a national high-stakes clinical skills examination. We also continue to explore the stability of candidate performance and the extent to which so-call...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03407.x

    authors: Eva KW,Reiter HI,Trinh K,Wasi P,Rosenfeld J,Norman GR

    更新日期:2009-08-01 00:00:00

  • The life long challenge of expertise.

    abstract::The development and maintenance of expertise in any domain requires extensive, sustained practice of the necessary skills. However, the quantity of time spent is not the only factor in achieving expertise; the quality of this time is at least as important. The development and maintenance of expertise requires extensiv...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.2001.00831.x

    authors: Guest CB,Regehr G,Tiberius RG

    更新日期:2001-01-01 00:00:00

  • Self-explanation in learning clinical reasoning: the added value of examples and prompts.

    abstract:CONTEXT:Recent studies suggest that self-explanation (SE) while diagnosing cases fosters the development of clinical reasoning in medical students; however, the conditions that optimise the impact of SE remain unknown. The example-based learning framework justifies an exploration of students' use of their own SEs combi...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章,随机对照试验

    doi:10.1111/medu.12623

    authors: Chamberland M,Mamede S,St-Onge C,Setrakian J,Bergeron L,Schmidt H

    更新日期:2015-02-01 00:00:00

  • New consultants mastering the role of on-call supervisor: a longitudinal qualitative study.

    abstract:CONTEXT:The supervision of specialty registrars during on-call shifts is essential to ensure the quality of both health care and medical education, but has been identified as a major novelty and stressor for new consultants in the transition from specialty training. There is a paucity of research on how consultants dea...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/medu.12129

    authors: Westerman M,Teunissen PW,Fokkema JP,Siegert CE,van der Vleuten CP,Scherpbier AJ,Scheele F

    更新日期:2013-04-01 00:00:00

  • Student assessment in undergraduate medical education in the United Kingdom, 1998.

    abstract::This report describes the results of the project 'Assessment of Undergraduate Medical Education: Re-inventing the Wheel?' funded by the Nuffield Trust. The project was initiated in order to obtain information on current assessment practices in medical schools across the UK, to determine the extent of change as a conse...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.2000.0340s1001.x

    authors: Fowell SL,Maudsley G,Maguire P,Leinster SJ,Bligh J

    更新日期:2000-09-01 00:00:00

  • Implementation of problem-based learning in Asian medical schools and students' perceptions of their experience.

    abstract:BACKGROUND:Since the introduction of problem-based learning (PBL) at McMaster University in 1969, many medical schools in the USA, Canada and Europe have included PBL in their curricula. In the past decade, many medical schools in Asia have also done so. However, so far no one has questioned whether the outcomes expect...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.2003.01489.x

    authors: Khoo HE

    更新日期:2003-05-01 00:00:00

  • Medical communication: the views of simulated patients.

    abstract:CONTEXT:Simulated patients (SPs) are extensively used in the teaching of medical communication, both for students and doctors. They occupy a unique middle ground between patients and physicians: although free from the prejudices that medical training brings, they work closely with clinical tutors to promote the princip...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/medu.13547

    authors: Laughey W,Sangvik Grandal N,M Finn G

    更新日期:2018-06-01 00:00:00

  • Supporting Pre-registration House Officers: the needs of educational supervisors of the first phase of postgraduate medical education.

    abstract::The GMC's publications The New Doctor (GMC 1997) outlines an approach for the education of Pre-registration House Officers using designated educational supervisors. In order to establish appropriate means of training consultants to undertake this role, the Centre for Postgraduate and Continuing Medical Education at th...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.1998.00209.x

    authors: Challis M,Williams J,Batstone G

    更新日期:1998-03-01 00:00:00

  • Current efforts in medical education to incorporate national health priorities.

    abstract::As a reflection on the Edinburgh Declaration, this conceptual synthesis presents six important challenges in relation to the role of medical education in meeting current national health priorities. CONTEXT:This paper presents a conceptual synthesis of current efforts in medical education to incorporate national healt...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/medu.13395

    authors: Nair M,Fellmeth G

    更新日期:2018-01-01 00:00:00

  • Career preferences of graduate and non-graduate entrants to medical schools in the UK.

    abstract:OBJECTIVE:Recent UK policy has been to increase substantially the number of graduate entrants to medical schools. Our aim was to study whether graduate and non-graduate entrants have different long-term career preferences. METHODS:We conducted postal questionnaire surveys of medical qualifiers from all UK medical scho...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2929.2007.02706.x

    authors: Goldacre MJ,Davidson JM,Lambert TW

    更新日期:2007-04-01 00:00:00

  • A study of a multi-source feedback system for international medical graduates holding defined licences.

    abstract:OBJECTIVE:To develop and assess the feasibility and psychometric properties of multi-source feedback questionnaires to monitor international medical graduates practising in Canada under 'defined' licences. METHOD:Four questionnaires (patient, co-worker, colleague and self) were developed and administered in 2 phases t...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02410.x

    authors: Lockyer J,Blackmore D,Fidler H,Crutcher R,Salte B,Shaw K,Ward B,Wolfish N

    更新日期:2006-04-01 00:00:00

  • Louder than words: power and conflict in interprofessional education articles, 1954-2013.

    abstract:CONTEXT:Interprofessional education (IPE) aspires to enable collaborative practice. Current IPE offerings, although rapidly proliferating, lack evidence of efficacy and theoretical grounding. OBJECTIVES:Our research aimed to explore the historical emergence of the field of IPE and to analyse the positioning of this ac...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 历史文章,杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/medu.12668

    authors: Paradis E,Whitehead CR

    更新日期:2015-04-01 00:00:00

  • When I Say…Self-Conscious Emotions.

    abstract::Imagine you are an intern intubating a patient when you are suddenly interrupted by the blaring sirens and flashing lights of the hospital's fire alarm. How would this make you feel? You would likely experience surprise, fear, and panic, all of which are basic emotions intended to generate a "fight-or-flight" response...

    journal_title:Medical education

    pub_type: 杂志文章

    doi:10.1111/medu.14425

    authors: Nguyen LN,Bynum WE

    更新日期:2020-12-01 00:00:00